Seriously. I mean it. Stop reporting anything Jeff Rubin (CIBC’s Chief Economist) has to say. If you need to quote someone about aspects of the economy, quote me — I’m right more often than Rubin.
I’m not kidding.
This past summer when oil prices were in the triple digits, Rubin was fear-mongering with talk about $200 barrels of oil being on the horizon. I, on the other hand, called it a bubble that would burst before the year was up. Who was more accurate? (Don’t believe me? Ask any of my customers who came in to buy investment books about that time - we had some heated conversations…that’s Pennywise Books at 1031 Rosser Avenue in Brandon).
Nor was that the only time that Rubin has been significantly wrong. He just “revises” his predictions. For example, in early December of 2008, he cut his prediction for the TSX in 2009 from 12,000 to 11,000. Today?
“Even with a second-half recovery, it is hard to see the TSX beyond 9,000 by the end of the year,” Rubin said.
To be fair, he’s a modern-day oracle, inhaling the fumes of ink and CPU-emitted ozone, spewing out indecipherable babble which is then translated for the “benefit” of those who listen — meaning he’s bound to be wrong a good portion of the time. We just need someone to look into the future for us.
The problem with Rubin is that his attempt to divine the future are not helpful at all. Going back to the example of the $200 oil, his predictions encouraged additional speculation by, well, speculators which led to further inflation of the petro-bubble. (Again, in fairness, there were other culprits too, but this rant is about Rubin, so back off.)
Today, Rubin is again NOT helping. Most commentators are in agreement that in order for the economy to get bak on track, investors need to start investing again. What does Rubin do? Of course. He encourages them NOT to:
Essentially, while many forecasters see a Canadian economic recovery in the cards in the next six months, Rubin said that scenario is not a given.
Gross domestic product in both Canada and the United States should continue to shrink in the second quarter, he said. As well, the U.S. banking crisis will keep leaking into the valuations of Canadian financial institutions, driving down the stock market prices of Canada’s banks and other finance firms, Rubin said.
The TSX should begin to recover by the end of 2009, Rubin said, but only to a level equal to its closing one year earlier.
I’m going to go out on a limb here and say that Rubin doesn’t know jack. I’ll even go a step further and make my own prediction and readers can evaluate for themselves who is the betterr forecaster.
I say that, yes, there are still some troubles to be seen, but Rubin is overly pessimistic. I say that NOW is the time to be buying stocks (and I do indeed put my money where my mouth is). I say that with the international attention that Canadian banks are receiving, we’ll see the stock prices of Canadian banks begin to climb very soon. These rising financials will pull up the TSX, dragging some other stocks with them (sorry Nortel, not you). Oil will continue to languish. By the end of 2009, we won’t be fully recovered, but it won’t be just beginning.
Sure, I may be wrong. If I am and Rubin is right, I’ll tip my hat to him.
That doesn’t change the fact that the media should stop reporting his Debbie Downer claims. The public needs to have some good news — some reason to stop hoarding cash and putting back into circulation. Reporting Rubin’s pessimism is of no help to anyone in any way.
I just needed to get that off my chest.