As I alluded to before, dads don’t get much respect. As parents, they seem to play perpetual second-fiddle to moms. That’s partly due to biology, of course, and partly due to culture, but I think there’s a significant (and probably growing) number of dads out there who want to be as deeply involved in their children’s lives as any mom — and they deserve to be taken seriously, and not mocked as dunder-headed fools for trying.
A couple of recent posts on a New York Times blog have highlighted that point for me. Ostensibly a parenting blog, it goes by the name “Motherlode” but the blogger, Lisa Belkin, has been trying her best to keep it inclusive to moms and dads, as well as to single-parents and other non-traditional family types. And good for her.
But sometimes she misses the mark.
Take this post, called “Diary of a Neanderthal Dad“. If you look at the URL when you click on it, you can see that the original title of the post (immortalized in the html) was actually “Talking Slowly To Dad So He Understands.” It presents the first-person tale of a dad who always feels like he is a step or two behind his wife and their kids, making him seem like the neaderthal surrounded by homo sapience. He just can’t keep up:
Neanderdad scratched at the hair between his shoulder blades with a thick finger. Everyone was talking to him like he was the child. His own frustration increased. To settle the matter, Neanderdad did what he did on the hunt. He decided. He commanded.
“Drink only in kitchen!”
…
In the kitchen there was more crying. Neanderdad heard his mate explain to his daughter, “Daddy doesn’t know about this sippy cup. To keep it simple, everyone has to follow Daddy’s rule …. We need to keep it simple for Daddy.”
After being blasted in the comments for posting a story that effectively emasculates dads by showing them as unable to parent effectively at all, Belkin replied:
Hmmm, interesting how this is being read. I thought it was a humorous dig at the Mom-Knows-Best dynamic (NOT a good one) that grows up in (too) many households. The point — at least the one I got — was that his wife was wrong, that the shutting him out rankles, and that this was a way of sending that message with honey rather than vinegar. A riff on the stereotype.
If there is any critique of the mom in the piece, it’s subtle, at best. And the dad-as-neanderthal imagery is so heavy-handed, I wouldn’t be surprised if the mom-critiques were unintended (or perhaps subconscious). Read it — and the 75 comments, if you want — for a brief introduction to the “dads get no respects” vs. “that’s because dads don’t do anything” battle that seems to be the current front in the gender war.
A second recent post was also a guest-post by a father, Paul Hankes Drielsma, trying to examine how to be an involved parent while surrounded by a culture that seemed to put moms first. Dads with kids, he writes, are often greeted with a cheery, “So, babysitting today?” as if he wasn’t a real parent. Can you imagine asking a mother if she was “just babysitting?”
It comes to a head when he tries to take his child to a parent-shild yoga class:
At the top, the flyer read “Mommy & Me Yoga” in 40-point font. At the very bottom, it added “Dads welcome!” in a font sized appropriately for the disclaimers in last second of a car commercial. When I arrived for my first class, the other participants (all mommies) glanced at me suspiciously. A few reached nonchalantly for their diaper bags and removed their Hooter Hiders, designer covers for discreet breastfeeding. It was clear that, to some, I had intruded into an environment where these were not supposed to be needed.
…
“Mommy & Me” is catchy and alliterative, and, in my neighborhood, it’s the standard label for parent-child events, whether fathers are welcome or not. The term is also unapologetic in its exclusion of fathers, and no analogue exists: the top results for a similar Google search for “Daddy & Me” include disturbing news items about horrific domestic violence.
Language, of course, tends to lag behind chages in culture. But culture warriors know this — that’s why we now have firefighters instead of firemen, for example.
As families move away from the two-parents, mom at home, dad working model of the idealized 1950s, there is going to have to be a shift in language that reflects the fact that parenting, now, is more gender-neutral than ever before.
The blog doesn’t offer any suggestions, but it’s a thoughtful and balanced exploration of the issue, and I really enjoyed reading his take on it. Belkin, for her part, seems sympathetic but slightly defensive, writing in the introduction:
And yes, I know I am running this critique of gender-laden language in a blog titled the Motherlode. I have mixed feelings about that title. On the one hand, it is a play on words, and a catchy one at that. It also reflects the reality that the heavier “load” of parenting responsibility still falls to women.
I’ve done some thinking about possible other titles for her blog, and I’ve only come up with two that I think are any good: “Rear Guard” and “Kidding Around.” Both are flawed. “Rear Guard,” playing off how people need to rear a child, but also alluding to diaper changes and the fact that parenting can be a battle, is simply too obscure. Not many people will associate it immediately with parenting. “Kidding Around” sounds too light-weight and almot humourous for a blog that is actually fairly well-thought-out, most times.
Any other suggestions out there?
I’d be curious, too, to hear what other people think about moms vs. dads and how they re treated and viewed by our culture.