Vibram Five Fingers first wearing review: As barefoot as I wanna be

I just took my inaugural run in a pair of Vibram Five Fingers.

I’ve blogged about these before, but a couple of weeks ago, I finally took the plunge, putting my money (and feet) where my mouth was, and I ordered a pair.

Hilariously, on the same day that Amy called to tell me that I owed her $12.47 for taxes and border fees due on delivery (thanks, Canada Post!) I spotted a guy at the gym wearing the exact same pair that I had ordered. He told me that he loved his (whew) but that his first run in them had really been a workout for his calves.

After a couple of days wearing them sporadically around the house, getting used to them on my feet, I finally took them to the gym this afternoon.

I guess it hasn’t really sunk in yet — although I packed my Vibrams, I also made sure that I took a clean pair of socks. Habits.

Putting them on is a work in progress. Remember learning how to tie your shoes? Vibrams will help you. Although it’s velcro, wriggling your toes into each individual pocket is an exercise in figuring out your neural pathways, akin to learning how to wiggle your ears.

It turns out that I am right-footed, just like I am right-handed. This assumption comes because it was far, far easier for me to get my right foot into the Vibrams than my left. There are all kinds of tips and tricks — Vibram Five Fingers are the only shoes Iv’e ever seen that actually have instructions on the inside flap of the box — but nothing beats experience. Because I’ve worn “regular” shoes so long, my baby toes each curl underneath my, um, ring toes? Anyway, there’s a definite Chinese-foot-binding thing going on down there (look again at the picture atop this post, and you’ll see it) and Vibrams are designed to remedy that. They “lift and separate,” you might say, like a Wonderbra for feet.

Actually, after a while, my baby toes started to feel somewhat akin to a thumb — they felt oddly like they were sticking out, although it was just that they were pulled away from underneath my other toes for a change. It wasn’t uncomfortable. In fact, it was pleasant, a bit like a light massage or a stretch.

After a weird feeling walking through the hallways and up the stairs at my local YMCA (it felt like I was both conspicuous and doing something illicit) I stretched out and got on the treadmill.

There is a lot less cushioning in these shoes than there is in a regular pair of shoes. You immediately notice the texture of the flooring, for example, whether it’s tile or carpet or wood planks. Overall, it’s good, but different. And, when I got on the treadmill, I quickly noticed that the “impact-cushioning” surface is not as I remembered it from my Nikes.

During walking, as I warmed up, the Vibrams were comfortable, but nothing unusual. It just felt like I was on the treadmill barefoot — and, again, like I was doing something illicit.

When I started running, though, is when I really noticed a difference. I quickly got over my thoughts of feeling “different” or conspicuous. I quickly started feeling tired.

I didn’t have any issues adapting to a new running style, although I did notice that I was “reaching out” with my foot, and landing closer to the ball of my foot, not on my heel. It felt fine — nothing felt unusual or different, although it clearly was. But my calves were burning. And my feet themselves were starting to feel tired, almost like I was running through sand.

There are tons of little muscles in my foot (Wikipedia says “more than a hundred muscles, tendons, and ligaments”) and they weren’t used to being run on like this. It was like I had taken a cast off, and now I needed the physiotherapy.

Not due to tiredness, but I was only able to spend about 10 solid minutes on the treadmill before I started feeling a hotspot on my left instep. Knowing that I was on the way to getting a blister, I hopped on a stationary bike instead.

I didn’t feel any different on a bike than if I had been wearing regular shoes. The treadmill was different — and, I think, better. As soon as I’m able to go a little longer, and a little faster, I think the blister will take care of itself. It’s a problem I have every spring with sandals anyway.

Longtime and diligent readers will recall that I first got interested in barefoot running because I had developed persistent, nagging foot pain while training for a half marathon last year. So far, no pain!

Now, I’m really looking forward to getting out there, running in the wild, with these shoes. I’m curious to see if my toes spread out more naturally, too. I’ll keep you posted.